Industry representatives in Guyana are calling on the government to reconsider its plan to build a state-owned water bottling facility costing $496.3 million. The Guyana Manufacturing and Services Association has argued that channelling public funds into a government-run bottling operation risks undermining private companies that have spent years building the local market for bottled water.

The dispute follows the National Assembly's approval of the funding, which will place the new plant under the management of Guyana Water Incorporated, the national utility provider. The government has framed the project as part of a wider ambition to achieve full self-sufficiency in domestic bottled water production. The GMSA has said it supports that broader goal, though it disagrees sharply with the method chosen to pursue it.

The association's objections centre on what it sees as unfair competition. Private manufacturers have already committed significant capital to local infrastructure, staffing and distribution networks built up over a period of years. Introducing a well-funded, state-backed competitor into a market that is already functioning, the GMSA argues, threatens to erode the value of that investment almost overnight.

There is also concern about the wider signal this sends to investors. A government entity entering direct competition with businesses it also regulates creates an unusual dynamic, and manufacturers fear it could discourage future private investment in the sector. The GMSA has pointed out that this approach appears to sit awkwardly alongside the government's own stated commitment to private sector-led industrial growth. A policy encouraging local firms to expand is difficult to reconcile with a state project that competes with those same firms for market share.

Central to the association's argument is an alternative approach the government itself floated earlier this year. The President had previously proposed a collaborative model in which the public and private sectors would work together to reach local production targets, rather than the state building and operating its own standalone facility. That earlier proposal included the idea of shared infrastructure, such as a centralised facility for manufacturing bottles, which would lower overhead costs across the industry rather than concentrating investment in a single government-run plant. According to the GMSA, this option was discussed in meetings with the Ministry of Public Utilities and Aviation held earlier in the year, and the association has questioned why that direction appears to have been abandoned in favour of the current plan.

Beyond the economic argument, the GMSA has raised a separate question about whether the project fits within GWI's core responsibilities. The utility's primary function is to deliver safe and reliable drinking water to households across the country, a task that remains a challenge in parts of Guyana where supply can be inconsistent. The association has suggested that directing GWI's resources and management attention toward a commercial bottling venture could pull focus away from that fundamental obligation. Whether a utility built around public water delivery is well placed to run a retail bottling business is, in the GMSA's view, a legitimate question that has not been adequately addressed.

The association has now formally petitioned the government to pause the investment before construction proceeds further. It is seeking renewed consultations involving industry stakeholders and the Ministry of Public Utilities and Aviation, with the aim of developing an approach that keeps costs down for consumers while supporting rather than displacing existing local manufacturers. The GMSA has framed this as consistent with, not opposed to, the government's self-sufficiency target, arguing that the target can still be met without placing the state in direct competition with the businesses that built the sector in the first place.

No date has yet been set for further talks, and the government has not issued a public response to the GMSA's request.

‍